Thinking about a new fence? You’re not alone. Many Alberta homeowners ask the same question: Should I choose wood or vinyl fencing?
Fences do more than just mark property lines. They add privacy, improve safety, and boost curb appeal. Choosing the right fence matters. Let’s break down the pros and cons of wood vs. vinyl fencing so you can decide what works best for your home.
Wood fencing: classic and customizable
Wood fences have long been a favourite for homeowners. They’re timeless, affordable, and easy to customize. You can paint or stain them to match your home, deck, or garden shed. This gives your yard a warm, natural look that feels inviting.
Benefits of wood fencing:
- Affordable upfront cost
- Easy to customize
- Adds rustic charm
- Works well for privacy
Things to consider:
Wood fences need regular care. In Alberta’s harsh weather, wood can warp, crack, or rot. You’ll need to clean and stain or paint your fence regularly. Wood is also vulnerable to insects like termites.
If you love the look of wood and don’t mind a little upkeep, this could be a great fit.
Vinyl fencing: durable and low maintenance
Vinyl fencing is a modern alternative that’s quickly growing in popularity. It’s made from PVC (polyvinyl chloride), a type of plastic that holds up well against wind, snow, and sun.
Benefits of vinyl fencing:
- Strong and weather-resistant
- No painting or staining needed
- Easy to clean with soap and water
- Resists insects and rot
Things to consider:
Vinyl costs more up front. But it saves time and money long-term because it doesn’t need as much care. It’s also less flexible when it comes to changing its look—what you see is what you get.
If you want a long-lasting, low-maintenance fence, vinyl is a solid choice.
Key things to think about
1. Cost
Wood fencing is usually cheaper to install. But rising lumber prices can change that. Premium woods like cedar cost more than basic options like pine.
Vinyl fencing costs more at first, but you’ll save on maintenance over time. That can make it the more affordable option in the long run.
2. Maintenance
Wood fencing needs:
- Cleaning
- Staining or painting
- Repairs over time
Vinyl fencing needs:
- Occasional wash with soap and water
- Rarely any repairs
If you’re busy or want something hassle-free, vinyl wins here. But wood offers more flexibility if you like changing the colour or fixing sections yourself.
3. Durability
Vinyl fencing stands up to Alberta’s extreme weather. It doesn’t warp, splinter, or rot. Our vinyl fences are made with durable ribbed panels (not hollow), which adds strength and reduces breakage.
Wood fences can also last 15–20 years—but only with regular care and upkeep.
4. Curb appeal
Both types of fences can boost your home's appearance.
Wood offers:
- Natural charm
- Warm tones and grain patterns
- A traditional, timeless feel
Vinyl offers:
- Clean, modern lines
- Many colours and textures
- Consistent look year after year
Love variety? You can repaint a wood fence anytime. Prefer simplicity? Vinyl keeps its look with no effort.
5. Privacy and security
Wood fences offer great privacy. The solid structure blocks views and reduces noise.
Vinyl fences can also offer privacy, but some designs have small gaps between slats. That said, you can add decorative inserts or panels for extra coverage.
Think about how much privacy and security you need before choosing.
6. Environmental impact
Wood is renewable but harvesting it can affect the environment.
Vinyl is made from recyclable PVC. Our vinyl fencing uses low-petroleum materials and has a 20-year life cycle. If you’re thinking long-term, vinyl can be the eco-friendlier option.
Which fence is right for you?
Both wood and vinyl have strong points. Your best choice depends on your budget, maintenance preferences, style, and climate. Think about what matters most to you.
Need help deciding? ATCO Energy fencing experts are here for you. We’ll look at your property, talk through your goals, and help you find the fence that fits your home—and your lifestyle.
Let’s build the perfect fence for your Alberta home. Contact us today for expert advice and a free estimate.
